Running an insurance agency comes with a variety of responsibilities, from guiding clients to managing operations and planning for the future. One essential aspect that’s easy to overlook but crucial for success is understanding which products and services generate the most profit for your business. This process, called profitability analysis, helps you focus your time and resources on what really works for your business.

Let’s break it down in a simple, actionable way so you can uncover your agency’s most profitable offerings and make smarter decisions for growth.

What Is Profitability Analysis?

Profitability analysis is the process of evaluating your products or services to see which ones generate the most profit. It’s not just about revenue (how much money comes in)—it’s about what’s left over after you’ve covered all the costs associated with selling a product or service.

For insurance agencies, your "products" might include auto, home, or life insurance policies, while your "services" could involve financial planning or risk assessments.

Why Does It Matter?

1. Boost Profits
   By identifying your most profitable products, you can focus your energy on selling and marketing them more effectively.
2. Cut Costs
   If a product or service isn’t profitable, you can decide whether to reduce costs, reprice it, or phase it out entirely.
3. Strategic Growth
   Knowing what works allows you to plan for the future and invest in areas that will deliver the biggest return.

How to Analyze Profitability

Here’s a step-by-step guide to performing a profitability analysis:

1. List Your Products and Services

Start by listing all the products and services your agency offers. This could include different types of insurance policies, endorsements, or add-on services.

2. Calculate Revenue for Each

Look at the revenue each product or service brings in. For example:

• Auto policies: $100,000/year
• Life policies: $70,000/year
• Financial planning services: $30,000/year

3. Subtract Costs

Identify the costs associated with each product or service, including:

• Staff time (e.g., selling, servicing, or processing claims)
• Marketing expenses
• Carrier fees
• Technology or software costs

For example:

• Auto policies cost $60,000 to manage.
• Life policies cost $30,000.
• Financial planning costs $20,000.

4. Calculate Profit Margins

Profit margin = (Revenue - Costs) ÷ Revenue × 100
Using the example above:

• Auto policies: ($100,000 - $60,000) ÷ $100,000 = 40% profit margin
• Life policies: ($70,000 - $30,000) ÷ $70,000 = 57% profit margin
• Financial planning: ($30,000 - $20,000) ÷ $30,000 = 33% profit margin

5. Compare and Prioritize

Now you know which products or services are the most profitable. In this example, life insurance policies have the highest profit margin, so they might deserve more attention in your sales strategy.

What to Do With This Information

• Double Down on Winners
  Invest more in marketing and selling the products with the highest profit margins. Train your team to focus on these offerings.
• Improve Underperformers
  If a product has a low profit margin, look for ways to cut costs or reprice it. For example, can you automate parts of the process or renegotiate carrier fees?
• Phase Out Low Performers
  If something isn’t profitable and you can’t fix it, consider removing it from your lineup. This frees up resources for more profitable opportunities.

Get Help from Experts

Navigating profitability analysis and cash flow management can feel overwhelming, especially if you're juggling multiple responsibilities. That’s where Club Capital’s CFO advisory team can step in. Their team of experts specializes in helping insurance agency owners analyze financial performance, manage cash flow, and plan for sustainable growth. From identifying your most profitable products to building a long-term financial strategy, Club Capital provides the tools and insights you need to make informed decisions and drive your agency’s success.

Pro Tips for Insurance Agencies

• Use Technology: Many accounting or agency management systems can generate profitability reports. Leverage these tools for accurate data.
• Track Trends: Profitability can change over time. Review your analysis regularly to stay on top of shifts in customer demand or costs.
• Ask for Feedback: Talk to your clients to understand what they value most. This can help you tailor your offerings to meet their needs and boost profitability.

Quick Takeaways

Profitability analysis helps you understand where your money is coming from—and where it’s going. By focusing on your most profitable products and services, you can maximize your earnings, cut waste, and grow your insurance agency strategically.

Start your profitability analysis today and set your agency up for long-term success! If you want to speak with a financial expert about your agency's profitability, contact us for a free demo.

More Tools

We recommend utilizing these tools to improve your agency's understanding and profitability:

Agency Tool Chest

Agency Toolchest amplifies your KPIs and reporting capabilities, providing a clear roadmap for your agents' success. Harness the synergy of sales gamification and targeted coaching to push beyond limits.

The Humble 100

If you're tired of inconsistent marketing results, struggling to track your sales performance, or wishing you could determine your best performing leads, the TheHumble100 is for you.